Provincial Court Judges lead Criminal Law Clinic for 42 years

Posted to: 
Judges
02/08/2016

Over 40 years ago Provincial Court Judge Jack McGivern started a clinical criminal law program at the University of British Columbia (UBC) Allard Law School. It provided an opportunity each year for 16 UBC law students to be trained by experienced criminal lawyers – defence and Crown counsel – and to conduct criminal trials and sentencings in the Provincial Court at 222 Main Street, Vancouver, where Judge McGivern presided.

Offered since 1974, this highly successful course has given countless students their first real exposure to the practice of criminal law, and many have gone on to become respected defence lawyers and Crown prosecutors after they were “called to the Bar” (became lawyers through certification by the Law Society of BC). Judge Joseph Galati has been the adjunct professor for the course for several years, succeeding Judge McGivern when he retired from the Bench.


UBC’s Allard School of Law
Photo Credit: UBC’s Allard School of Law website

The Criminal Law Clinic is a 6 credit course offered in the second term each year, from January through April. The aim of the course is to teach basic familiarity with the skills required for the practice of criminal law. Since these skills can be transferred to any type of litigation and the students find the training they receive invaluable, the course is very popular. Enrolment is limited to 16 students, but there were more than 40 applications for the up-coming term.


Experienced criminal lawyers volunteer their time and act as principals to the successful student applicants. The students are required to obtain Temporary Articles from the Law Society of British Columbia and are subject to its Code of Professional Conduct as well as to the provincial Legal Profession Act. They are, of course, also subject to the direct supervision of their principals. Preparation for each year’s course begins in September with an orientation session in which the successful student applicants are paired up with lawyers. Their applications for Temporary Articles are completed and sent to the Law Society.

Then supervising lawyers start identifying suitable cases for their students to handle and schedule trials or guilty pleas for the upcoming term. Generally, each lawyer takes on two students who are encouraged to work together in the preparation of their cases. If students do not have a matter set for a particular week they are required to attend court as observers. Lawyers attend court with their students to supervise their conduct of trials and guilty pleas. The lawyers often allow the students to attend and sometimes to participate in some of their other cases.

Classes are held on a weekday from 5 to 8 pm. Students are required to attend every week and generally all of the supervising lawyers attend. During a class, all the cases students have conducted in the last week are debriefed. Three or more Provincial Court judges and a Supreme Court judge usually attend to participate in discussions that invariably touch on ethical issues and strategy as well as procedure, evidence and substantive law.

Judge Galati knows the criminal law clinic well. He was a student in the course, and then volunteered as a supervising lawyer before becoming the course instructor. He comments, “Of particular value is the fact that both defence and prosecution perspectives are discussed and debated in virtually every case after it has been completed. The students learn experientially but also from the critiques and comments of their fellow students, supervising lawyers and judges. They come away with a thorough and rounded understanding of best practices in criminal litigation.”